Match each 4-bit signed addition in Column I with the correct description in Column II of the carries at the most significant bit and the correctness of the stored 4-bit signed result.
Column I:
P:
Q:
R:
S:
Column II:
(i) , , and the stored result is not the correct signed sum
(ii) , , and the stored result is not the correct signed sum
(iii) , , and the stored result is the correct signed sum
(iv) , , and the stored result is the correct signed sum
Here is the carry into the most significant bit and is the carry out of the most significant bit.
A
Step-by-Step Solution
Key idea: this is a carry-in/carry-out matching question. Do not decide correctness from the final carry alone. Compute the carry into the MSB and the carry out of the MSB separately, then check whether the stored result equals the true signed sum.
Step 1: P: .
No carry reaches the MSB and no carry leaves it, so , . The stored result is , which is correct. Thus P matches (iii).
Step 2: Q: with a carry out.
The lower three bits produce no carry into the MSB, so . The sign-bit addition produces . The true sum is , which is not representable in 4 bits, so the stored result is not correct. Thus Q matches (i).
Step 3: R: .
The lower bits generate a carry into the MSB, so . At the MSB, with no carry out, so . The true sum is , not representable in 4-bit signed form, so the stored result is not correct. Thus R matches (ii).
Step 4: S: with a carry out.
The bit below the MSB generates a carry into the MSB, so . At the MSB, gives sum bit 1 and carry out 1, so . The true sum is , which is representable, and the stored result is . Thus S matches (iv).
Step 5: Elimination confirms the only matching satisfying all four rows is P-(iii), Q-(i), R-(ii), S-(iv).
Answer: option A.