Insight: Equal red and blue after 2 steps means exactly 1 red and 1 blue were drawn — use exchangeability or direct enumeration.
Exam route: Start: 1R, 1B. After 2 steps, total = 4. Equal counts need 2R and 2B, so exactly k=1 red drawn. By exchangeability: P=(12)⋅1(1)⋅1(1)/2(2)=2⋅1⋅1/6=1/3. Select B.
Learning route:
This is a Polya Urn state question, identifiable by the reinforcement mechanism (draw, replace, add one of the same colour) and the question asking about the urn's composition after a fixed number of steps.
Setup: Initial state: 1 red, 1 blue, total 2. After 2 draws, total = 2+2=4 balls. For equal red and blue counts, we need 2 red and 2 blue, which means exactly 1 red and 1 blue were drawn in the 2 draws.
Method 1 — Direct enumeration:
List all possible sequences of 2 draws:
- RR: P=21⋅32=31 → final: 3R, 1B (not equal)
- RB: P=21⋅31=61 → final: 2R, 2B (equal ✓)
- BR: P=21⋅31=61 → final: 2R, 2B (equal ✓)
- BB: P=21⋅32=31 → final: 1R, 3B (not equal)
P(equal)=61+61=31
Method 2 — Exchangeability formula:
P(k reds in n draws)=(r+b)(n)(kn)⋅r(k)⋅b(n−k)
With r=1,b=1,n=2,k=1:
P=2(2)(12)⋅1(1)⋅1(1)=2⋅32⋅1⋅1=62=31
Wrong path walkthrough: A student who treats draws as independent coin flips computes P(exactly 1 head in 2 flips)=(12)(1/2)2=1/2, matching option C. The mistake is at the independence assumption: in a Polya Urn, the second draw's probability depends on the first draw's outcome. The reinforcement mechanism makes draws dependent, reducing the probability of mixed outcomes.
Generalisation: In a Polya Urn, reinforcement amplifies early outcomes, making "all same colour" more likely and "mixed" less likely compared to independent draws.
Verification: The four sequence probabilities sum to 31+61+61+31=1. ✓
Answer: B) 31