An urn contains one red ball and one blue ball. At each step, a ball is picked uniformly at random from the urn, and this ball together with another ball of the same color is put back in the urn. The probability that there are equal number of red and blue balls after two steps is
B
Step-by-Step Solution
Insight: Equal red and blue after 2 steps means exactly 1 red and 1 blue were drawn — use exchangeability or direct enumeration.
Exam route: Start: 1R, 1B. After 2 steps, total = 4. Equal counts need 2R and 2B, so exactly red drawn. By exchangeability: . Select B.
Learning route:
This is a Polya Urn state question, identifiable by the reinforcement mechanism (draw, replace, add one of the same colour) and the question asking about the urn's composition after a fixed number of steps.
Setup: Initial state: 1 red, 1 blue, total 2. After 2 draws, total = balls. For equal red and blue counts, we need 2 red and 2 blue, which means exactly 1 red and 1 blue were drawn in the 2 draws.
Method 1 — Direct enumeration:
List all possible sequences of 2 draws:
- RR: → final: 3R, 1B (not equal)
- RB: → final: 2R, 2B (equal ✓)
- BR: → final: 2R, 2B (equal ✓)
- BB: → final: 1R, 3B (not equal)
Method 2 — Exchangeability formula:
With :
Wrong path walkthrough: A student who treats draws as independent coin flips computes , matching option C. The mistake is at the independence assumption: in a Polya Urn, the second draw's probability depends on the first draw's outcome. The reinforcement mechanism makes draws dependent, reducing the probability of mixed outcomes.
Generalisation: In a Polya Urn, reinforcement amplifies early outcomes, making "all same colour" more likely and "mixed" less likely compared to independent draws.
Verification: The four sequence probabilities sum to . ✓
Answer: B)