Context: A housing committee uses a priority scoring system for 4 applicants: A (Base 80), B (Base 70), C (Base 60), D (Base 50).
There are two types of exceptions:
- Type X: +20 points. Eligible if Base Score < 70.
- Type Y: +30 points. Eligible if Base Score < 60.
Rules:
- Exceptions are allocated in order of Base Score (highest first).
- There is exactly 1 slot for Type X and 1 slot for Type Y.
- An applicant can claim only one exception.
- Tie-breaker: If final scores are equal, the applicant who claimed the exception with the higher point value gets priority. If the exception values are the same, the one with the higher base score wins.
Applicant B realizes that by intentionally reducing their base score to 69 (e.g., by resigning and rejoining), they would become eligible for Type Y instead of Type X.
If B successfully games the system by reducing their base score to 69, what will be the final allocation order (from highest priority to lowest)?
B
Step-by-Step Solution
Key idea: This is a system gaming question recognisable by the eligibility thresholds and the incentive to manipulate base scores.
Step 1: Determine the new base scores. A=80, B=69 (gamed), C=60, D=50.
Step 2: Allocate exceptions in order of base score.
- A (80): Not eligible for X (<70) or Y (<60). Score = 80.
- B (69): Eligible for X (<70) and Y (<60). Since exceptions are allocated highest base first, B picks first. B will pick Y (+30) because it's higher. Score = 69 + 30 = 99.
- C (60): Eligible for X and Y. Y is taken by B. C gets X (+20). Score = 60 + 20 = 80.
- D (50): Both taken. Score = 50.
Step 3: Rank the final scores.
- B: 99
- A: 80
- C: 80
- D: 50
Step 4: Resolve the tie between A and C. Both have 80. A has no exception (value 0). C has Type X (value 20). C wins the tie-break.
Final Order: B, C, A, D.
Wait, let me re-evaluate the tie-breaker rule. "the applicant who claimed the exception with the higher point value gets priority". A claimed NO exception. C claimed X (+20). So C wins.
Order: B, C, A, D.
Let me check the options. Option C is "B, C, A, D".
Wait, in my thought process I said Option B is "B, A, C, D". Let me fix the solution to match the correct option.
If B=99, C=80, A=80. C wins tie over A. So B, C, A, D.
Let me adjust the options in the YAML to make "B, C, A, D" the correct answer.
Answer: C