Common Description:
Read the following scenario and answer the THREE questions that follow.
Comprehension: Raghubir, a reputed doctor, practices medicine in a tier-three city. He owns an importedSUV which he bought 10 years ago, using his hard- earned savings of nearly 5 years.Initially, he used to take it for long rides, but for the last 6-7 years, he only commutes to hisclinic, a 10-minute drive from his home.
The SUV has been his proud possession but it demands high maintenance. Also, thediesel-guzzling SUV does not comply with the new emission norms being introduced in thetier-one and tier-two cities. Of late, a few newspapers reported that the new emission normsmay be introduced in tier-three cities as well. This news has worried Raghubir.
The new emission norms are about to get implemented in tier-three cities, andRaghubir’s city will follow suit shortly. Hence, Raghubir starts exploring options ofbuying an electric vehicle(EV). He lists the following factors that will guide him onbuying an electric car: P. EVs within Raghubir’s budget can cover his daily commute, but not the long rides.
Q. A new electric SUV in the market, within his budget, nearly has the same look andfeel of his present SUV.
R. EVs cannot be driven beyond a speed of 70 kmph.
S. New charging stations on the main highway, connecting his city to the closestmetro city, may come up in another year.
T. The only shop, selling EVs in his city, is ready to trade in Raghubir’s SUV at areasonable price.
The above listed factors have been arranged in a DECREASING order of in uence inthe options given below.
Which of the following options will BEST help Raghubir buy an electric vehicleimmediately?
Step-by-Step Solution
Key idea: This is a consumer purchase prioritization question, recognizable because it asks to rank factors in "DECREASING order of influence" for an immediate purchase decision under specific constraints.
Step 1: Identify the primary goal. Raghubir wants to buy an EV "immediately" to replace his aging, high-maintenance SUV before new emission norms hit.
Step 2: Evaluate the factors based on immediate feasibility and relevance to his core needs (budget, daily commute, disposal of old car).
Step 3: Rank the factors.
- Q (Look/feel + budget) is most influential because it addresses his emotional attachment and financial constraint immediately.
- T (Trade-in at a reasonable price) is second, as it solves the immediate problem of disposing of his old asset to fund the new one.
- P (Covers daily commute) is third, validating that the EV meets his primary, current use case (10-minute drive), even if it fails his past use case (long rides).
- S (Future charging stations) is fourth, as it is a future benefit, not an immediate deciding factor.
- R (Speed limit of 70 kmph) is last, as he no longer takes long rides, making top speed irrelevant to his current needs.
Step 4: Match the ranking Q, T, P, S, R to the options.
Answer: C