Four companies (Alpha, Beta, Gamma, Delta) reported their Revenue and Cost (in Rs. crores) for the years 2022 and 2023. Profit is defined as Revenue minus Cost.
The following facts are known:
- The total profit of the four companies was exactly in 2022 and in 2023.
- For each company, the Profit in 2022 was an even integer, and the Profit in 2023 was an odd integer.
- For each company, the Profit strictly increased from 2022 to 2023.
- The absolute increase in Profit () was a distinct positive integer for all four companies.
Which of the following statements is/are NECESSARILY true?
i. The minimum absolute increase in Profit among the four companies was exactly .
ii. The maximum absolute increase in Profit among the four companies was at least .
iii. The sum of the absolute increases of the two companies with the highest increases was exactly .
D
Step-by-Step Solution
Key idea: This is a logical deduction question relying on integer constraints and parity (odd/even properties).
Step 1: Determine the parity of the increases.
Let be the 2022 profit (even) and be the 2023 profit (odd).
The increase is .
Since , every company's absolute increase in profit MUST be an odd integer.
Step 2: Set up the sum constraint.
Total increase in profit = .
Let the four distinct positive odd increases be .
We know .
Step 3: Find all valid sets of .
The smallest distinct positive odd integers are (Sum = ).
To reach a sum of , we must add to these base values while keeping them distinct and odd.
Possible sets:
- Set 1: Add to the largest . (Sum = )
- Set 2: Add to the third and to the largest . (Sum = )
- Set 3: Add to the second (Invalid, not distinct).
- Any higher starting values (e.g., ) sum to .
Thus, the ONLY possible sets of increases are and .
Step 4: Evaluate the statements against both valid sets.
- i. Minimum is exactly : True for both and .
- ii. Maximum is at least : True ( and ).
- iii. Sum of the two highest is exactly : For Set 1, . For Set 2, . True for both.
All three statements are necessarily true.