Assertion (A): The number of distinct valid pop sequences for the input pushed onto a single initially empty stack in that order is 42.
Reason (R): A valid sequence of 5 pushes and 5 pops corresponds to a Dyck path of length 10. The total number of unrestricted paths is , and the number of invalid paths (which dip below the starting level) is , making the valid count .
A
Step-by-Step Solution
Key idea: The number of valid stack permutations of elements is given by the -th Catalan number, which is derived using the reflection principle on lattice paths.
Step 1: Evaluate Assertion (A). The number of valid pop sequences for is the 5th Catalan number, .
Step 2: Calculate . Thus, A is true.
Step 3: Evaluate Reason (R). A push is an up-step and a pop is a down-step . A valid sequence never has more pops than pushes at any prefix, corresponding to a Dyck path that never dips below the x-axis.
Step 4: The total number of paths with 5 up-steps and 5 down-steps is .
Step 5: By the reflection principle, the number of invalid paths (those that touch ) is equal to the number of paths from to , which requires 4 up-steps and 6 down-steps. This count is .
Step 6: The number of valid paths is . Thus, R is true.
Step 7: R provides the exact combinatorial proof (the reflection principle) for why the count in A is 42. Therefore, R is the correct explanation of A.
Answer: A