Consider the following logical rules for a server cluster:
- The cluster is healthy () if the CPU usage () is below 80% and the network is stable ().
- The cluster triggers an alarm () unless it is healthy () and the power is redundant ().
- The power is redundant () only if the network is not stable ().
It is observed that the cluster is healthy ( is True), no alarm is triggered ( is False), and the CPU usage is below 80% ( is True).
Which one of the following is the CORRECT truth value of the network being stable ()?
A
Step-by-Step Solution
Key idea: This is a multi-step propositional translation question. The trap lies in correctly translating the keywords "if", "unless", and "only if" into their precise logical implications without reversing the arrows.
Step 1: Translate Rule 1. " if ( and )" means the condition () is sufficient for . Translation: .
Step 2: Translate Rule 2. " unless ( and )" means if ( and ) is false, then happens. Translation: .
Step 3: Translate Rule 3. " only if " means is sufficient for , or is necessary for . Translation: .
Step 4: Substitute the given truth values: , , .
Step 5: Evaluate Rule 2. Since is False, the antecedent must be False (to avoid a True False scenario). Therefore, must be True. Since is True, must be True.
Step 6: Evaluate Rule 3. Since is True, and , the consequent must be True. Therefore, must be False.
Step 7: Verify Rule 1. becomes , which is . This is a valid implication (vacuously true).
Answer: The truth value of is False. Option A.